What Gmail, Yahoo!, AOL, and Hotmail Have in Common with the NSA

Posted by Natalie Roemer on

The National Security Administration and mailbox providers share a common charter to protect their installed customer base from outside, unwanted threats. What’s more interesting, is that their means of doing so are not hugely dissimilar.

The NSA relies on a science called signals intelligence. Basically, this is a method of gathering and analyzing aggregate signals, including communication and behaviors by and between people to determine some pattern that suggests a potential threat. This intelligence is often matched to profiles of individuals or groups of individuals to determine an actual threat probability.

Similarly, many larger mailbox providers such as Gmail, Yahoo!, AOL, and Hotmail look at and analyze aggregate signals to assign some probability that incoming mail could be a threat: spam, phishing, or spoofing. In these cases, the mailbox provider may look at obvious signals like users flagging mail as spam (This is Spam = TIS signals) or the alternative, moving messages from their spam folder into their inbox (This is Not Spam = TINS signals).

Beyond the obvious, they may factor several other signals into their determination of what is or isn’t a threat, including mail being deleted without having been read, mail being forwarded to a friend, or the aggregate read rates by sender. All of these behavioral signals are assessed in the context of sender profile signals like IP address sending permanence, list hygiene indicators (unknown user rates, spam trap hits), and content risks (bad or suspicious links, poorly rendering HTML, etc.) to determine whether the mail should safely pass through to their subscriber base, or whether the threat should be interrupted at the gateway (filtered to the spam/junk folder or blocked entirely).

blog_nsa_table

Luckily for players in the bulk email world, the allowable thresholds for these signals are not top secret. By having continual access to mailbox performance for over two thousand senders, Return Path has been able to observe the correlation between the rates at which these signals present for any given sender, and the rate at which mail gets delivered to the inbox for the same.

In aggregate, this intelligence powers Return Path’s Inbox Optimizers, which allow email marketers to zero in on where their own mail may be pushing the limit on tolerable thresholds, even as the thresholds dynamically adapt to the email community’s appetite for bulk mail, and as the mailbox providers evolve their filtering methodologies. For more details on how mailbox providers use both engagement and reputation signals to guide their filtering, see this recent article.

And you thought this was going to be about how Gmail, Yahoo!, AOL, and Hotmail spied on personal email communication! As interesting as that may be, they’ve got big enough fish to fry just trying to keep their users safe from unwanted mail, and happy receiving what does arrive in their inboxes.


Popular this Month

 3 Trends Impacting Email: Persistent Fraud, Part 2

3 Trends Impacting Email: Persistent Fraud, Part 2

In part one of this three-part series, I examined the evolving landscape of...

Read More

 The Top 16 Topics of 2016

The Top 16 Topics of 2016

2017 is finally here! But before we focus on the year ahead, we wanted to...

Read More

 Think Fighting Email Fraud is Someone Else’s Job? Here’s the Real Cost of Doing Nothing.

Think Fighting Email Fraud is Someone Else’s Job? Here’s the Real Cost of Doing Nothing.

Cyberattacks against your brand can be very damaging and costly to both your...

Read More

Author Image

About Natalie Roemer

Natalie Roemer is a Technical Account Director at Return Path. Her brain's passion for analytics, consulting, and communication has found its zen in her current role. In her spare time, she can be found skiing on the snowy beaches of the Rocky Mountains, or creating something artsy at home. Connect with her at linkedin.com/in/roemernatalie.

Author Archive

Stay up to date

Enter your name and email address below to subscribe to our mailing list.

Your browser is out of date.
For a better Return Path experience, click a link below to get the latest version.